Review: The Wine-Dark Sea

Victoria Hislop, The Wine-Dark Sea, ‎(Review, 2026)

https://www.goodreads.com/review/edit/247114113

A painful saga of a family divided by war

The Nazi occupation of Greece has brought ‘sinister change’ to the village of Kalopetra and the family of Fotini and her daughter Iliana. The civil war spreading across the country has already provoked strife between Fotini’s husband and her sister Stella’s communist husband. Then Stella, Fotini and Fotini’s baby Mitsos are carted off by government soldiers to a detention camp for suspected communists.

Iliana and the other children are left stranded in the village to fend for themselves, until they are rescued by communists, who take them from one training camp to another.

Stella, Fotini and Mitsos spend years in one detention camp or another, suffering untold hardships and atrocities. Fotini looks after a friend’s child Nikos until they, too, are separated, and we follow his journey as he is transported to an orphanage sponsored by Queen Freideriki, which is just as cruel.

It’s hard enough reading about children separated from their parents. This book was a painful read. It would be so gratifying to read the communists as ‘the good guys’, yet that does not seem to have been Greece’s experience. Page after page describes hardship and injustice, ameliorated by the occasional kindness and camaraderie they meet along the way. Thank goodness, there’s a happy ending.

The title invites a comparison to the travels of Odysseus, with similar themes of hardship, separation and even revenge. It’s very Greek, too, peppered with expressions in the original language. The descriptions of food had me rushing to Google for recipes.

Politics is not much discussed in the book. I found that frustrating, but it seems to have been a deliberate choice by the author. One never really understands why people are being transported here and there. This would probably have mirrored the experience of the children, but the adults don’t understand what is going on, either. Of all the characters, straight-thinking four-year-old Nikos seems to have the greatest understanding.

People I’ve spoken to say that the experiences of the civil war were so distressing that there are still today families that won’t have anything to do with families who back then were on the other side.

Comments

Leave a Reply