Brendan Gerad O’Brien, A Crack in the Ice (Kindle 2025)
1945 Tralee, Ireland.
Marcus Fanning kissed goodbye Amanda Hayes, perhaps never to see her again, reminiscing about the accident that had changed his life, the torpedo attack on the ship where he’d been serving as steward. It was in hospital that he’d met Amanda, a nurse. The famous actress whose life he’d saved had hired him as her butler, and he was on his way to Waterford. In his satchel he carried something which was to affect the lives of many.
25 years later Frankie Rowe stumbles on the satchel, and later he is found dead.
Garda detective Eamon Foley and Sergeant Kelly chase down the theft of a silver cigarette case from a jewellery store. The owner Delta McKay was already known to the Gardaí. Her much older husband Michael McKay had apparently committed suicide leaving everything to her and cutting out his grown children, and there is a legal dispute ongoing.
The thief was Marcus Fanning’s pretty daughter Florence. Delta’s history is more complicated than we had realised, and so is the story of her husband’s demise.
The guards gradually uncover more of the story—Marcus and Amanda’s liaison, the circumstances of Michael McKay’s and Frankie Rowe’s deaths. The characters involved in both cases turn out to have connections with each other, as well as connections with the guards and their families. This person used to date that person; this person bought their house from that person. And information dribbles out in what seems a realistic way. This person overhears something in a pub; that person sees something on their way home from work.
I never guess who the murderer will turn out to be, but in this case, I think enough clues are given so that the conclusion doesn’t just come out of the blue. Yet it’s still quite innovative.
At the first there are some uncomfortable shifts in tense for flashbacks—that’s often difficult. And I thought that Eamon Foley, supposedly the star of the show, plays too minor a role until the latter half of the book. I would have liked for more of the story to have been told through his eyes.
The characters are colourful, with interesting and believable dialogue, and the plot is lively. This is altogether a jolly murder mystery that keeps the reader guessing right up to the end.
Brendan Gerad O’Brien has written several novels. Gallows Field and A Pale Moon was Rising also feature Guard Eamon Foley.









