Robin Holloway, The Better Angels (Holand Press 2025)
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/8009771617
The invasion of St. Helena Island in South Carolina by the Union forces drives away the white planters, leaving the ex-slaves considered ‘contrabands of war’, neither free nor slave.
Northern white abolitionists like Laura Towne build a school to educate the children.
While initially flabbergasted by the differentness of the culture and frustrated by their subservience, Laura spends her whole life loving and working in the good interests of ‘her people’.
The ‘Port Royal Experiment’ is sincerely dedicated to bettering the lives of the ex-slaves, but there is debate on how to go about it. Some think the most important thing is to return the cotton fields to productivity and integrate the ex-slaves into the capitalist system. Laura loves and respects them, but fears for their vulnerability in the new world. Jupiter, the elegant black carriage driver, believes the blacks must fight for their freedoms.
The first year’s cotton crop is not good, so they are ‘forced’ to list the plantations for sale. Mr Philbrick is trusted to make the initial investment, promising to offer plots to the freedmen ‘when it is possible’, but ‘possible’ keeps getting delayed. Will they get their ‘40 acres and a mule’ as promised? Will they get the vote?
The structure is a mixture of diary entries, letters and exposition. Some of the exposition seems to be in the POV of Jupiter, but this is not clear. A very worthy subject, but as a novel, I found myself wanting a love story or some drama, or some slight fault in Laura’s angelic character.
This is all about the psychology of oppression and the complexity of relationships when love is mixed with exploitation. It is also about angels. Fortunately, there are people on this earth and in history who dedicate their lives to making the world a better place.
This review first appeared in Historical Novels Review.









